Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

Managing the Life Cycle Costs of Pumping Systems

Industry News
Annual Costs of Typical Pumping System

Managing the Life Cycle Costs of Pumping Systems

Author: Henri Azibert

As we discussed in last month’s article, there are costs in pumping systems that are often overlooked.  We analyzed the potential cost of leaks, and this month we are going to look at all the various constituents of operating an industrial system.  The initial and most obvious cost is that of the equipment itself.  Much attention is paid to it.  Requests for quotes are sent out, comparisons are made, and arduous negotiations ensue.  However, the entire cost of operating the equipment through its effective life is most often ignored.

Below is a list of the typical component costs associated with a system.

  • initial purchase (equipment, support system, auxiliary services)
  • installation and commissioning
  • operating cost (labor cost of normal system supervision)
  • equipment maintenance (parts, man‑hours)
  • Equipment support system maintenance & repair
  • down time and loss of production
  • environmental
  • energy
  • decommissioning and disposal

The image shows a typical repartition of the various costs.  The numbers will vary depending on the actual application, but this example would be fairly typical. When a piece of equipment is purchased, such as a pump, a valve, or a seal, the prime consideration is the acquisition cost or purchase price.  Little attention is paid to the other actual costs of installing, operating, and eventually decommissioning the equipment. Prospective vendors are contacted, different options are evaluated, and the one with the lowest purchase price is most likely to be chosen.  Yet this selection can easily be the most expensive solution over the life of the equipment. The initial cost is but a small constituent of the overall costs; most often energy costs are by far the largest factor.

There are a number of tools used to evaluate an investment in capital machinery.

  • Simple Payback (SPB)- Time for the capital investment cash inflows to equal outflows.
    • The main advantages are that it is a good first screening method, easily understood and applied, and a simple method to compare merits of different projects. The disadvantages are that the time value of money not considered, the timing of cash flows is usually not included, and you cannot effectively distinguish between projects with the same payback periods.

Simply Payback Example

    

  • Internal Rate of Return (IRR) – Rate of return on capital invested.
    • The main advantages are that it shows annualized rate of return over time, and it is a widely used and accepted method
    • Disadvantages includes that it does not consider scale of project, the projects with highest IRR are not necessarily the highest priority, and it assumes the invested project cash flow brings equal return over the life of the project.

Internal Rate of Return Example

 

  • Present Value (PV) – Value on future payments
    • Discounted for time value of money – It can include risk & inflation
    • It employs the present value of future costs and uses a specified Discount Rate
  • Net Present Value (NPV) – Sum of the present values of all expected future cash flows taking into account multiple cash flows (incoming & outgoing)
    • The advantages are that is considers time value of money, calculates PV of all costs for given discount rates. It is a very precise method.
    • The main disadvantage is that it is sensitive to the reliability of future cash inflows

There are calculators available from Association websites that can help with detailed calculations. Operating costs need to be factored in any capital purchase decision.  What can be an initial saving of $200.00 can easily turn in an extra cost of $1,000,000.00 over the typical 20-year life of an industrial system.  Life cycle costs should be the determining factor in choosing between alternative systems as it is the only accurate measure of the profit that can be realized over the useful life of the equipment.

 

Related Articles

Related Whitepapers

Design Optimization of Jet Fuel Pump for Aviation

Jet fuel pumps play a critical role in the safe and efficient operation of commercial aviation. The performance and reliability of these pumps directly impact…

The Cost Of Downtime In Manufacturing [Infographic]

Downtime can be the most expensive element of any manufacturing operation. Here are some important facts and tips you should know to cut down on…

AFT Fathom used to Model Central Heating Cycle of a State-of-the-art Combined Heat and Power Plant

Kerem Algüzey, design engineer at ENKA Insaat ve Sanayi A.S., used AFT Fathom to simulate the central heating cycle to inform the design of the…

Driving Energy Savings a Commercial Facility Energy Upgrade Project

Upgrading to Design Envelope pumps helped GAC save energy costs of 20,000 AED in the first year. Armstrong’s Pump Manager service provides reports and notifications…

Comments

One response to “Managing the Life Cycle Costs of Pumping Systems”

  1. Bradley Ford says:

    Pump reliability is extremely important and a paramount concern for many of our clients. With one of the warmest festive seasons on record in the UK, this year the winter has been extremely mild so far. But in recent years the worse of the winter weather has started after Christmas in January and February. Cold weather has the potential to cause critical problems to heating systems both commercial and private, as they struggle to cope with increased demand.

    Of course, the equipment is usually the most expensive, but in some cases maintenance can cost a lot of money too in terms of the cost to actually fit it and any down time which may occur.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *