Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

Cost Savings Through VFD Integration in a Drinking Water Distribution System

Pumps & Operations
HI Cost Savings Through VFD Integration in a Drinking Water Distribution System

Cost Savings Through VFD Integration in a Drinking Water Distribution System

Intended Audience: Water Distribution

Objective: Replace the constant speed motors with VFD driven motors to match the varying flow rate demand of the water distribution system.

Description of System: A drinking water distribution system serving a small residential community—operating without a hydro-pneumatic tank—draws water from a reservoir using two booster pumps (one duty, one standby). Each pump is powered by a 22-kW (30 hp) constant-speed, standard-efficiency induction motor controlled via an across-the-line starter. The system is designed to maintain a consistent pressure of 550 kPa (80 psi) using a hydraulically controlled bypass relief valve, which discharges excess water back to the suction reservoir. Each pump is rated for 90 m³/h (400 gpm) at 550 kPa (80 psi) and 75% pump efficiency. The system is graphically represented below:

HI Cost Savings Through VFD Integration in a Drinking Water Distribution SystemFigure 1: Schematic with constant speed drive and bypass relief valve

The following diurnal flow rate demand curve illustrates the average hourly demand over a typical 24-hour period. Over the course of a typical 24-hour day, the flow rate varies from 19 m³/h (85 gpm) to 90 m³/h (400 gpm). The shaded region above the curve but below the 90 m³/h (400 gpm) curve represents the flow rate being recirculated through the bypass relief valve.

HI Cost Savings Through VFD Integration in a Drinking Water Distribution SystemFigure 2: Constant speed system and pump performance curve

The following diurnal flow rate demand curve illustrates the average hourly demand over a typical 24-hour period. Over the course of a typical 24-hour day, the flow rate varies from 19 m³/h (85 gpm) to 90 m³/h (400 gpm). The shaded region above the curve but below the 90 m³/h (400 gpm) curve represents the flow rate being recirculated through the bypass relief valve.

HI Cost Savings Through VFD Integration in a Drinking Water Distribution SystemFigure 3: Diurnal flow rate demand curve

Under the existing configuration, the system consumes approximately 483 kWh per day, totaling 176,295 kWh annually. At an energy rate of $0.10/kWh, the yearly operating cost is $17,643, with an additional $750 in routine maintenance.

Description of Intervention: The system was upgraded with Variable Frequency Drives driving premium efficiency induction motors of the same size, at a capital cost of $30,000. The bypass valve and associated recirculation piping were removed and replaced with a pressure transmitter installed on the pump discharge manifold. This transmitter enables dynamic speed control of the pump, maintaining the target pressure of 80 psi while adjusting flow rate in response to real-time demand.

HI Cost Savings Through VFD Integration in a Drinking Water Distribution SystemFigure 4: Schematic with VFD

The power draw of the pump during periods of non-peak demand is reduced in accordance with the flow rate demand, saving energy throughout the day. The difference between constant speed power and the power draw of a variable speed option is illustrated below.

HI Cost Savings Through VFD Integration in a Drinking Water Distribution SystemFigure 5: Power consumption curve

By modulating motor speed during periods of reduced demand, the system significantly lowers energy consumption. Post-upgrade, daily energy usage dropped to 323 kWh, resulting in an annual consumption of 117,895 kWh and a reduced energy cost of $11,779—a savings of $5,864 per year. Importantly, operation and maintenance costs remain unchanged.

Summary of Results: An LCC analysis is performed to compare costs between the original and new systems. A summary is provided in Table 1:

Table 1 LCC analysis

LCC Elements Original New
Initial Investment N/A $30,000
Annual Energy Cost $17,643 $11,779
Annual O&M Cost $750 $750
Total Annual Cost $18,393 $12,529
Annual Savings N/A $5,864
Total lifetime cost at present value $204,501 $169,302

Over the course of the project life, the new system saves $35,200. The payback summary is reported below in Table 2.

Table 2: Simple payback summary of new system

Annual energy cost before installation $17,643
Annual energy cost after installation $11,779
Annual energy cost savings $5,864
Project capital cost $30,000
Project Life 15 Years
Discount Rate 4 %
Net present value $35,200
Simple payback 5.1 Years
IRR 17.9 %

Conclusion: This retrofit demonstrates how transitioning from constant-speed motors with bypass control to VFD-driven systems can yield substantial energy and cost savings, while enhancing operational responsiveness and sustainability in municipal water infrastructure. VFDs can also alternate pump operation to prevent backup pump seizure and ensure even wear across both units.

Written by: Members of the Committee, 1st Edition
Published In: Pump Systems Optimization: A Guide for Improved Energy Efficiency, Reliability, and Profitability
Year of Publication: 2018

Related Articles

Related Whitepapers

Arrow Powers Gas Turbine Analysis at Fern Engineering

Fern Engineering, Inc. was contracted by a major refinery to reduce the exhaust gas temperature variations of their gas turbine fleet. According to Hector Bourgeois,…

2027 DOE Efficiency Mandate & The Case for Higher Efficient Motors

The 2027 DOE motor efficiency requirements are bringing important changes to industrial motor applications. In this presentation, ABB’s Courtney Pickett and Stefanie Casimir break down…

ENKA Designs a State-of-the-Art District Heating System for Hamburg’s CHP Plant

Datacor Fathom provided the best solutions in terms of both heat transfer and pressure loss calculations.” – Kerem Algüzey, ENKA Industry: Power Generation Region: Hamburg,…

Refinery Cooling Water System Calibration Using Datacor Fathom

Hydrus Works, LLC needed to recalibrate a large refinery cooling water system containing nearly 600 pipes, 492 junctions, and 127 heat exchangers. Over 700 pressure,…